Defending Against Domestic Violence Allegations in Washington, D.C.: A Comprehensive Guide

by | Jan 19, 2024 | Defenses

Understanding the Rules and the Players

Facing domestic violence allegations in Washington, D.C. is a serious matter with significant legal and personal repercussions. The city’s legal system takes these cases seriously, and it is essential to navigate the complexities effectively. Domestic violence in Washington, D.C. is broadly defined as offenses including assault, battery, stalking, and threats when they occur within intra-family or household relationships. These relationships encompass not only blood relatives but also individuals sharing a residence, reflecting the city’s commitment to addressing violence within close-knit units.

A.  Prosecution of Domestic Violence Matters in Washington, D.C.

The Office of the Attorney General’s Domestic Violence Unit is dedicated to handling cases related to domestic violence. The prosecutors in this unit are tenacious and highly experienced in navigating the unique challenges associated with these matters, bringing charges against individuals accused of domestic violence offenses. Their focus on intra-family or household relationships aligns with the city’s aggressive policies aimed at addressing and combating violence within these close-knit units. Understanding the role and the policies of the OAG’s Domestic Violence Unit is crucial for individuals and defense attorneys involved in domestic violence cases in Washington, D.C. It underscores the importance of a strategic and well-informed defense against these allegations.

B.  Washington, D.C., Domestic Violence Mandatory Arrest Law

Additionally, the city has a Mandatory Arrest Law, DC Code § 16-1031, emphasizing the gravity of domestic violence by mandating the arrest of an individual when there is probable cause to believe that such violence has occurred.  Generally, this decision is left up to the responding police officer(s). Unfortunately, this law  is overly broad and has resulted in the arrest of innocent individuals. At times, this law is misused in that the police will make an arrest to simply “cool down” the domestic situation. This comprehensive guide aims to assist individuals and their defense attorneys in understanding and navigating the legal landscape surrounding domestic violence allegations in the district.

9 Essential Steps to Prepare a Defense Against Domestic Violence Allegations

1. Gather Evidence:

To build a strong defense it is critical to collect evidence that contradicts the complaining witnesses  allegations. This may include text messages, emails, or eyewitness accounts that support the defendant’s version of events. Additionally, documenting the history of the relationship and any previous false accusations can be crucial in establishing a pattern. Preserving this evidence immediately is important to prevent it  from being destroyed or lost.

2. Witness Testimonies:

Identifying and interviewing potential witnesses can be instrumental in challenging the credibility of the accuser’s claims. Family members, friends, or neighbors who were present during the alleged incident may provide statements that contradict the prosecution’s narrative. A lawyer who is experienced in Domestic Violence defense should be working together with an investigator. To avoid making himself a witness to the case, the qualified attorney will have his investigator conduct these conversations.

3. Expert Testimonies:

Engaging expert witnesses, such as psychologists or counselors, can help provide insights into the dynamics of the relationship and may refute claims of abusive behavior. Experts can evaluate the mental health of the parties involved and offer their professional opinions in court. In addition, experts may be necessary to challenge government evidence such as injuries, cell tower location information – and more. A Washington, D.C. Lawyer who specializes in Domestic Violence defense will understand the importance of retaining experts and will know how to challenge the government’s expert witnesses.

4. Surveillance Footage:

In cases where the alleged incident occurred in a public place or within the home with surveillance cameras, obtaining and presenting relevant footage can be a powerful tool in proving innocence or highlighting inconsistencies in the accuser’s story.

5. Challenging Protective Orders:

Protective orders issued are often a part of domestic violence cases. The orders can impact a defendant’s access to their home, work or even children. A thorough examination of the order and challenging its basis, if unjustified, can be crucial. Defense attorneys should explore the possibility of modifying or lifting these orders to allow for contact between the parties.

6. Building a Timeline:

Establishing a clear timeline of events leading up to and following the alleged incident is essential. This timeline can help demonstrate that the accused was not present at the location or engaged in any threatening behavior at the time of the alleged offense. The timeline can also assist the investigator and the attorney in creating a successful defense.

7. Cross-Examination Strategies:

During the trial, defense attorneys should conduct a thorough cross-examination of the accuser to uncover inconsistencies or motives that may call into question the credibility of their testimony. This may include exploring any potential biases, personal issues, or ulterior motives.

8. Legal Defenses:

Understanding and applying relevant legal defenses, such as self-defense or defense of others, can be crucial in domestic violence cases. Demonstrating that the accused acted out of necessity or to protect themselves or others can be a valid legal argument. A qualified Washington D.C. attorney who specializes in domestic violence defense will know which defense to raise and how to implement it.

Stay Safe, Stay Informed and Contact a Skilled Washington, D.C. Domestic Violence Defense Lawyer.

Defending against domestic violence allegations in Washington, D.C. requires a strategic and comprehensive approach. By understanding the specific laws, gathering compelling evidence, and utilizing expert testimonies, individuals and their defense attorneys can build a robust defense. Navigating the legal system with diligence, professionalism, and experience is essential in securing the best possible outcome for those facing domestic violence charges in the district.

At Scrofano Law, we pride ourselves in having not only the most qualified but also highly dedicated attorneys who specialize in defending clients against Domestic Violence claims.    If you or a loved one has been arrested, or is the target of a domestic violence investigation, please contact us immediately.  Not only will we schedule you a free consultation, but our attorneys are happy to meet you in person at our Washington, D.C. office located only blocks from the Courthouse. Please stay safe and stay informed.

Joshep S.

Contact Us

Scrofano Law PC

At Scrofano Law PC, we believe in three simple principles. Honesty. We are always honest to our clients. We will never force or manipulate you to plead guilty or try to convince you to do something…

Martindale Hubbell Joseph Scrofano 2018
Share This